For those following along at home, I did find my desk, and here it is:
5 Unmasked by the Marquess, Cat Sebastian (e)4 Jimmy the Kid, Donald E. Westlake (e)3 Wanted, A Gentleman, KJ Charles (e) (read aloud with Steve)2 The Book of Atrix Wolfe, Patricia McKillip (e) (re-read)1 Proper English, KJ Charles (e)