rolanni: (Them 1980)
I'd meant to finish this set earlier. Unfortunately, book deliveries and more angst than usual at the day-job kind of distracted me.

Now, one of the things that people ask Steve and me about collaborating is how we resolve artistic differences; there are, after all, two of us and we must sometimes disagree. It is true that we do sometimes have different ideas about a story's direction or various technical details. Usually, these differences can be resolved by sitting down and talking, sometimes role-playing, until we're both on the same page again. Often, that page is not exactly what Steve had envisioned and not exactly what I had envisioned, but a blending of the two notions, all working (so we devoutly hope and believe) to strengthen the story.

And this is meet and just.

Sometimes, though, there arises. . .something that cannot be talked, role-played, or compromised away. Something that one of us feels So Very Strongly About that there is no compromise.

This is why each book has a traffic cop.

I suppose it must be the case with most long-time collaborators that some books are more the child of one partner's heart and intellect. Certainly, it's the case with Steve and me, and the traffic cop thus is the person who brought the idea for the story to the partnership. The traffic cop holds the third vote in any disagreement regarding that project; it is a tie-breaker vote, in case we cannot find agreement, and it is binding.

You may say that this is a broad and awesome power -- and you would be right.

That agreed, Steve has used his awesome tie-breaker powers exactly once, in a total of seventeen collaborative novels. I have also used my vote, enforcing my will and my vision on the story -- once.

The details of each case may be of interest, but as they contain spoilers, I'll continue behind the cut )
rolanni: (Them 1980)
It's funny how living in the country means that it's hard to take walks. When I lived in the Big, Bad City, I walked everywhere. When Steve and I first moved in together, we lived out in the 'burbs, though I thought it was the country (the difference between the 'burbs and the country is sidewalks),and we walked miles of an evening. When we lived in Waterville, we used to make the police nervous, because we would walk late at night, after the paper went to bed at midnight, and I'd walked home through the night-time downtown.

Out here in the True Country (no sidewalks for six miles in one direction -- no sidewalks 'til Bangor in another...) -- it's hard to walk. The shoulder is soft and stony, and the road traffic is cars that are driving too fast, and log trucks, ditto. In several seasons of the year, there are people of dubious good sense and/or sobriety, who are nevertheless armed, trekking in the woods and taking sound shots into the trees, toward and road or not makes no matter to them.

What does this have to do with collaboration, you ask?

Well, see, the reason Steve and I used to walk all those miles is because we were talking out what's known between us, and I may add, elegantly -- "Story Stuff."

"Story Stuff" is the measure of our household. Everything stops for "Story Stuff." We can be standing in the grocery store, studying on the virtues of spaghetti sauce, and if one of us says "Story Stuff," the shopping goes on hold until the scene/bit of dialog/forward plotting has been brought out and discussed. Our neighbors are used to it by now, and just shop around us. Summer people tend to keep their distance, even sending store employees down to fetch out what they want from the aisle we've taken over, rather than venture too near, themselves.

Now, what makes "Story Stuff" especially interesting is that -- we role-play. Mildly! No knife-fights in the breakfast food aisle. But certainly one or both of us have been known to adopt a Belligerent Stance from time to time in puruit of a plot point. Also? We talk about our characters as if they were, well, real. Because, to us, they are real. This can lead to some...fascinating assumptions on the part of those on the periphery of a "Story Stuff" conversation.

Like the time we were in -- was it Nashville? No, I'm wrong. We were in Louisville, for the NASFiC, back in Aught-Seventy-Nine. Steve and I are from Maryland, originally, and while my accent passed for "southern" up here before it got all scrambled around with Mainer and became, "Where did you say you were from?", in Louisville, they speak Southern.

So, picture this: Two ragged mid-coasters just in from a long drive, catching a cheap lunch at the HoJos before getting over to the con, and we're talking, in our fast, clipped, city accent, about a story. In fact, we're discussing a scene that some years later appeared in Agent of Change. What we're talking about, very earnestly, is the philosophy of weaponry and what sort of person would prefer a gun, and what sort a knife, in a given situation, and what might cause a person whose weapon of first choice is a blade to go instead for his gun, and --

We notice that our waitress is, well...hovering, within earshot. It's a funny hour, there aren't that many people in the HoJo's but we think maybe she's going off-shift and needs us to settle up before she can, or that the table needs to be made ready for the dinner setting, or --

Anyhow, we ask her if she needs the table.

"Oh, no!" she says, in that wonderful slow thing they've got going in the Real South. "No...It's just -- Y'all have such an interestin' family!"

Here ends the Second Riff.
rolanni: (Sharon with 10 Liaden Universe Books)
Steve and I have been collaborating for a long time -- seventeen novels, mumblemumble short stories; 25 years. Yeah, any of those qualifies as "a long time."

Our first collaborative story was "The Naming of Kinzel" -- which later became "The Naming of Kinzel: The Innocent" -- and it was an accident.

How, you wonder, can a collaboration be an accident?

Well, it went like this...

Steve and I were both in what we call the Opportunity Pool -- that happy place where, unencumbered by the strictures of a day-job, all opportunities are equally open to one. Which is to say, we were both "out of work," as the saying goes.

I was working on a story about a wizard's apprentice named Kinzel, who had just been Summoned by his Master to the tower workroom, in terms that left no doubt that said Master was none-too-pleased with his 'prentice. Kinzel was on his way up the stairs, puffing, because he was rather a portly lad, the Summons at his heels, when --

The phone rang.

It was the temp agency I was registered with, calling with the joyous tidings of a secretarial job at a law firm.

Next morning, quivering with joy, I rose at an Unghodly Hour(tm), dressed in my day-job clothes, and caught the bus into Baltimore City, leaving Steve home alone with three-quarters of a page of story still stuck in my typewriter and Kinzel frozen in mid-leap between one stair and the next.

The lawyers I was assigned to work for were brats (I learned during the course of the day that the firm had stopped hiring real legal secretaries for the pair of them, because they chewed the poor women up and spat them out in regular two week cycles); I came home exhausted and quivering not so much with the joy, but still on for the next day. I drank a glass of wine, had supper with Steve, had maybe another glass of wine and fell into my bed without once looking at poor Kinzel, still stranded on his stairway.

The next day was a repeat of the first. Against all odds, I was employed for the next day, and Kinzel was still stuck on his stair.

The third day. On the third day, Steve snapped.

He had reading and re-reading this same story-bit for three days; he'd been thinking about the character and the character's dilemma and what I had said about the character and his further travails, and, well --

He called me at work. He said, "You know that story you're working on? The one about the wizard's apprentice?"

"Yeeesss," I said warily.

"I think I know where it goes," he said, equally wary. "Could I...finish it?"

I thought about it. I thought about it long and hard. I knew he was interested in the story; he'd been asking me questions about it and where I saw it going and about Kinzel's background and the world he lived in, and, well, dern it, I wanted the story to move on, too -- and you know Kinzel was beyond sick to death of that damn stairway.

So, I said, "OK." Deep breath.

"But.

"If I don't like what you've done when I read it, I reserve the right to change it or to throw it out."

He agreed to the terms.

And when I came home, there was the first draft of story sitting at my place at the kitchen table.

Steve poured me a glass of wine, and I read it. I had some niggles. We talked about them and clarified some of the rougher bits of world building. The next day was Saturday. I rose from my bed, fetched myself some coffee and repaired to the typewriter, where I addressed my niggles and layered in some of those world building insights we'd had the night before.

By the end of the afternoon, we had a clean final story. All we had to do was figure out which of (at that point, many) magazines to send it to.

Here ends the First Riff.

January 2026

S M T W T F S
     1 2 3
4 5 678 9 10
11 12 13 14 15 16 17
1819 2021222324
25262728293031

Syndicate

RSS Atom

Most Popular Tags

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags